I have always been very happy cramming all my kit into a bum bag and worried about feeling hot and constricted in a hydration vest. A few longer races on hot days this summer when I had to resort to a day sac to carry fluids had made me think of investing (’scuse the pun) in one. When the club bought some vests from Swiftal, I thought I’d have a go.
As I have never used one before I can’t offer a comparison, but I must admit I’m a convert. I did a training run with full kit and a kilogram of water in a bladder in the sac. It was very comfortable, with no rubbing and it didn’t have to be cinched tight to stop it swinging about. For the Penmaenmawr race I carried a 500ml bottle in a pouch on a front strap (there is one on each side); this didn’t feel unstable, balanced just by a switched-off phone opposite. Four zipped pockets on the straps swallowed map, compass, whistle, buff, gloves and a Mars bar. I would have happily worn it all day - if the legs would have let me!
It’s a shame we couldn’t get it in club blue but the logos make it distinctive and smart. The only downsides I can see are it probably will be warm in hot weather - on Saturday I was glad for all the warmth I could get. Secondly, to get at your body cover or other contents of the main bag you would have to take it off, which I think would be a bit more fiddly than a rucksack. I’d certainly recommend it for longer runs. Have a look in the Goat Stuff Shop or via the club website.